Privatising the Beach

Capital accumulation turns natural environments into exclusive commodities, with governments constantly enabling the process and local communities bearing the cost.

Photo Credit: Matt Barnard

Around the world, natural space that was once freely accessible is increasingly becoming pay to play, and the communities who have historically lived alongside the coast are being progressively excluded from it. Behind this lies a process through which the natural world is treated as a potential commodity awaiting commercial use, and governments make choices in favour of investors over residents.

The mechanisms through which coastal enclosure proceeds are varied, but more or less consistent. The most widespread is the concession system, under which public administrations grant private operators the temporary right to occupy and commercially exploit public coastal land in exchange for payments that often undervalue what is being handed over. By 2021, 43 percent of Italian beaches were covered by beach clubs under such arrangements, with rentals in some Gargano locations reaching fifty euros a day for a single parasol, effectively pricing out working-class residents from their own coasts. In countries with communal land regimes, such as Mexico, a more direct form of dispossession is common through the appropriation of ejidal lands, which are territories collectively held and protected under agrarian law. This has led to the conversion of coastlines governed and used by communities into privately managed tourism infrastructure, often without any formal concession process.

Where legal frameworks inherited from colonial administration deny any automatic public right of coastal access, as in Jamaica, where only about 0.6% to 1% of Jamaica’s coastline remains freely accessible to the public, the state’s own title to the coastline becomes the instrument through which resort developers progressively absorb it. Different mechanisms and legal histories, but the outcome is the same. What was once held in common passes into private hands.

Why this happens at such a scale, and with such consistent support from governments, requires an explanation that goes beyond individual corruption or poor regulation. Coastal space has a distinctive economic property. The quality of the water and the ecological character of a given coastline cannot be reproduced elsewhere, and whoever controls access to them can charge accordingly, extracting a premium unavailable from any ordinary commodity. Scholars call this monopoly rent, which is a process of gaining profit from controlling something unique and irreplaceable rather than from producing anything. The pressure to capture that premium drives tourism toward a model in which economic elites effectively take over territories of exceptional natural beauty, offering access at prices only foreign visitors with high purchasing power can afford, while local populations are displaced from spaces they previously held in common.

Governments actively facilitate this. In Guanacaste, Costa Rica, hundreds of hectares of Pacific coastline were transferred to interests connected to former government ministers at roughly one dollar per square meter – land that is valued at around five hundred times that figure. The province became the country’s leading tourism region by hotel capacity, yet poverty indicators in the region worsened even as investment continued to grow. The pattern recurs wherever coastal tourism becomes sufficiently lucrative. International organisations, such as the UNCTAD, reinforce it by presenting continued coastal development as a driver of economic recovery, providing political justification for dispossession that might otherwise face greater public resistance.

Across every context where coastal tourism has expanded at scale, a familiar pattern of ecological degradation can also be observed. Loss of biodiversity accelerates as coastal ecosystems are destroyed to make way for resort construction, while freshwater resources are depleted by hotel infrastructure whose demands far exceed what surrounding communities need. What makes this particularly difficult to challenge publicly is a contradictory tendency within the same industry, one that has been described as neoliberal conservation, that is, the practice of using environmental protection as a commercial strategy rather than treating it as a public good. As mass resort development degrades accessible coastlines, a parallel market emerges in which exclusive operators sell access to pristine environments at premium prices, marketing themselves as conservation-minded alternatives to the damage mass tourism causes. Environmental protection is thus converted into a product available to those who can pay for it, while degraded public coastlines remain for everyone else.

The social consequences of privatisation are many, the most immediate is simple exclusion. Fences and pricing structures remove working-class and marginalised communities from coastal space, a loss that is often framed as the natural result of private enterprise providing services, when in reality the space being commercialised was public before it was privatised. The investment that privatisation attracts then raises the cost of living in surrounding communities, displacing the residents whose historical presence gave those places their character and value. Official tourism data, like the World Tourism Barometer, consistently presents these dynamics as growth success stories, reporting increases in visitor arrivals and income as evidence of broad economic benefit, without accounting for how that income is distributed or how much of it leaves the local economy entirely. 

Public space is where equality is exercised collectively, where people share a common environment regardless of income, and its privatisation fractures the social fabric of coastal communities, sorting access by the capacity to pay. The sharpest image of this fracture is the experience of local residents, who find themselves barred from access because their very presence is considered incompatible with the aesthetic the resort economy requires. As one local from the Mexican coastal city of Cancún puts it:

“In my personal opinion, I feel it’s used as a form of discrimination, as it’s as if they’re saying to you, ‘you’re a local and you have no business coming to this beach because I, as a hotel, am marketing this beach to my tourists, to my guests, and I only want them to use it; I don’t want you to disturb them with your presence, your music, your little drinks cooler or anything like that.’ So I feel that, to a certain extent, they discriminate against you for being a local.”

Against this, organised resistance has been persistent. In Mar de Plata, Argentina, neighbourhood assemblies have halted the fencing of coastal reserves and established them as collectively managed spaces. In Jamaica, legal campaigns have pursued the recovery of historically used beaches through the courts, combining arguments about rights with the practical case that artisanal fishing and local livelihoods depend on coastal access that resort development is extinguishing. These mobilisations share an insistence that coastal space carries obligations no concession framework can dissolve, and that the material and cultural benefits communities derive from the sea are not things market valuation can adequately measure.

What is ultimately at stake in that insistence is the naming of a particular kind of harm. Once the natural world is understood as a commodity, the deprivation that follows from enclosing it stops registering as deprivation, and appears instead as the normal operation of the market. Calling it injustice – as communities mobilising across these contexts consistently do, refuses that normalisation.

The narratives of development and conservation through which beach privatisation is legitimised, are the ideological mechanism by which enclosure is made to look like improvement.

Addressing the processes and the narratives that sustain them as a single political problem, rather than separating them into technical issues for different regulatory bodies to manage independently, is where any response capable of reversing privatisation has to begin.

Written by Kevin Picado